Statement : Should there be reservations in Government jobs for candidates from the single-child family? Argument : I. No. This is not advisable as the jobs should be offered to only deserving candidates without any reservation for a particular group. II. Yes. This will help reduce the growing population in India as the parents will be encouraged to adopt a single child norm. Options: A . &nbspif only argument I is strong; B . &nbspif only argument II is strong; C . &nbspif either I or II is strong; D . &nbspif neither I nor II is strong and E . &nbspif both I and II are strong.

Statement : Should there be reservations in Government jobs for candidates fr

Question

Directions: Directions: Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument. Give answer (a) if only argument I is strong; (b) if only argument II is strong; (c) if either I or II is strong; (d) if neither I nor II is strong and (e) if both I and II are strong.

Statement :

Should there be reservations in Government jobs for candidates from the single-child family?

Argument :

I. No. This is not advisable as the jobs should be offered to only deserving candidates without any reservation for a particular group.

II. Yes. This will help reduce the growing population in India as the parents will be encouraged to adopt a single child norm.

Options:

A . if only argument I is strong;

B . if only argument II is strong;

C . if either I or II is strong;

D . if neither I nor II is strong and

E . if both I and II are strong.

Answer: Option D
Answer: (d)
The Government has already made provisions for the reservation of jobs for the economically backward sections, which is a must. So, abolishing the practice of reservation altogether has no meaning.
Thus, argument I is vague. Also, more reservations would lead to the non-recruitment of many more deserving candidates. Besides, such a reservation, if implemented, will cater to the job requirements of only a small section of the population and not a major part of it.
So, argument II also does not hold strong.

Was this answer helpful ?