Question
A, B, C, D and E when arranged in descending order of their weight from top, A becomes third, E is between D and A, C and D are not at the top. Who among them is the second?
Answer: Option A
- - A E D
B C A E D
Hence, C is second among them.
---------- Another Explaination:
Was this answer helpful ?
- - - - -
- A - - -
D E A - - [It is not possible as D is not at the top]- - A E D
B C A E D
Hence, C is second among them.
---------- Another Explaination:
Let's analyze the given information step by step:
- A becomes third when arranged in descending order of weight from top.
- E is between D and A.
- C and D are not at the top.
From point 1, we know that A is not the heaviest since it's third from the top.
From point 2, we have two possibilities:
a. E is between D and A
b. A is between D and E
However, since A is already stated to be third from the top, option b is not possible. So, we proceed with option a.
From point 3, we know that C and D are not at the top. So, it implies that either B or E could be at the top.
Given that A is not the heaviest and C and D are not at the top, the order from top to bottom could be:
- B, E, D, A, C
- E, B, D, A, C
In both cases, C is second in descending order of weight.
So, the correct answer is (A) C.
Was this answer helpful ?
Submit Solution